Well Phillip, I'm glad you've started a new topic. After all, there is a lot to talk about the Samba rhythms. Everytime there was a new reply, I had to print the whole long story. I follow this discussion with interest.
It's all very funny. A lot of dancers including me come with a very long explanation and think that he or she is right. I think it is very hard to find out what the original Corta Jaca figure is. You can read a lot of books, but as Weddingdance wrote "Different books can say different things and it's open to interpretation".
And as Reyesuela wrote, there is a differents between social and competitive dancing.
4 quicks... 10 quicks and now 6 quicks. I have learned the Corta Jaca with 8 quicks. Let's look at it the other way. Perhaps the Corta Jaca is just the movement heal, replace weight, toe, replace weight. Ofcourse, you can use a lot of different rhythms and variations.
I have asked my teacher about the Corta Jaca and he explained me that we learn one of the many variations of the Corta Jaca.
If you dance a jive, you have two rhythms for the same figure. It depends on the music. You can have the beat values 1 - 1 - 1/2 - 1/2 - 1 - 1/2 - 1/2 -1 or 1 - 1 - 2/3 - 1/3 - 1 - 2/3 - 1/3 - 1. The last one is with triples.
I think every dance-teacher teaches in a different way. It's a pity that not everybody learns the same basic figures. This could be a problem if you want to dance with somebody from another dance school, but it could be exciting too!
If you don't understand the rhythm of a figure, you have to contact your teacher in the first place, but most of the time that isn't easy.
I thought there was only one way to dance the Corta Jaca. We have learned the Corta Jaca with a strange rhythm a1 a2 a3 a4, so you start the figure before count 1. I thought that Carol didn't understand that rhythm, because the basic rhythm is easy. That's why I replied to the topic.
Fred
------------------